6 Of The Best Eyeliners For Older Women

While we can't do anything about the aging process, we can invest in the right products to help keep our skin looking its best as we get older. This is especially true when it comes to eye makeup, and more specifically, eyeliner. If you are looking for quality eyeliners for mature women, look no further. We've researched the best ones, and in this post, we will share them with you.

A few qualities to look for in eyeliners for older women include easy application, water-proof capabilities, hypo-allergenic formulas for sensitive skin, and quick drying time, amongst others. Eyeliners with these qualities are easier on mature skin and tend to last longer. As you get older, finding the right eyeliner is important for comfort and a great finished look.

Here are 6 highly recommended eyeliners for older women:

  1. Maybelline New York Makeup Eyestudio
  2. It Cosmetics No-tug Waterproof Gel
  3. Physicians Formula Lash Boosting eyeliner
  4. Urban Decay Glide-On Eye Pencil
  5. Stila All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
  6. La Roche Posay Liquid Eyeliner

There are tons of different eyeliners available today, but narrowing down the best ones for your skin can be challenging as an older woman. Knowing what features to look for can minimize your search efforts and quickly lead you to eyeliners that'll work well for you. Let's take a closer look at some of these features as well as some of the best eyeliners that offer them.

woman with eyes closed, eye makeup. 6 Of The Best Eyeliners For Older Women

This article may include affiliate links and elements that were carefully created by our team using advanced ai to help you envision the best style advice.

Important Eyeliner Features For Older Women

Beautiful woman with bright make up eye with sexy black liner makeup.

Easy application

Before purchasing a new eyeliner, it's crucial to make sure that it's easy to use. Liners that have felt tips are the easiest to apply, as they glide on fairly smoothly. Minimizing the amount of tugging on the area beneath your eyes helps keep your skin looking youthful and taut. You'll also want to look for eyeliners that have easy-to-hold pens to avoid crooked and smudged lines.

Fast-drying times

Liners that dry fast are perfect for mature skin, as it means that you won't have to waste time waiting for the liner to dry. You also don't have to worry about smudging it when you apply your mascara.

Mild ingredients

Shop for eyeliners that do not contain harsh ingredients and chemicals. Many eyeliners today include several beneficial oils such as cotton C, vitamin E, and jojoba oil. These oils are great for mature eyes and can help moisturize your lash line and condition the skin around it.


Everyone has a different skin type. However, as you get older, you may notice that your skin is more sensitive than it was in your younger years. For this reason, it's helpful to go for eyeliners that are hypoallergenic to avoid eye irritation and allergic reactions.


Smudged eyeliner can be a real nuisance, especially when you're busy at work and don't have time to check it in the bathroom mirror. Look for eyeliners that are waterproof and have long staying power. It shouldn't be hard to find this feature these days, as most brands have waterproof options.

Now that you know what to look for in your next eyeliner, let's look at some of the best options.

The Best Eyeliners For Older Women

1. Maybelline New York Makeup Eyestudio

Maybelline's gel pencil is a good product to have in your arsenal if you're an older woman. It comes in multiple shades and has a smudge and grease-free formula that dermatologists and ophthalmologists have tested. This liner is easy on sensitive eyes and is hypoallergenic. It also has a 24-hour lasting time.

Read more about this pencil on Amazon.

2. It Cosmetics No-tug Waterproof Gel

If lasting power is your number one concern, this eyeliner is worth taking a look at. This soft pencil liner by It Cosmetics contains peptides, collagen, hydrolyzed silk, as well as antioxidants to help nourish the skin around your eyes. It's also a "no-tug" liner, which means that you don't have to worry about applying a lot of pressure. This waterproof liner can give you long staying power without irritation and smudging.

Find out more about it on Amazon.

3. Physicians Formula Lash Boosting eyeliner

This jet black liner by Physicians Formula is an easy-to-use liner that is perfect for mature skin. It contains mild ingredients for mature eyes and sensitive skin. The liner also includes a specialized serum to promote a healthier lash base. If you are looking for a mild liner that is water and smudge-resistant, here's a good one.

Check out this liner on Amazon.

4. Urban Decay Glide-On Eye Pencil

Another great pencil is the glide-on eye pencil by Urban Decay. This easy-to-use pencil lasts up to 24 hours and offers a smooth tug-free application. It's perfect for providing a long-term finish to smokey eyes or a quick touch-up to sharp lines. If you're looking for an intense pencil that offers creamy blending and a waterproof finish, this liner is worth checking out.

Take a look at this liner on Amazon.

5. Stila All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

Sometimes you may want a liner that dries within seconds. If so, here is a product worth considering. The all-day liner by Stila dries instantly and stays on for 24 hours without smudging. It also has a no-tug applicator and provides a pen-like finish. So whether you need a liner for a smokey eye look or a sharply curved line, this pencil can do it.

Read more about this liner on Amazon.

6. La Roche Posay Liquid Eyeliner

Here is another mild liner that is easy on sensitive skin and mature eyes. This liner dries exceptionally fast and offers all-day wear. Its non-toxic formula won't irritate your eyes or contact lenses, and you won't need to touch it up throughout the day. It's formulated with a natural wax that can provide a sharp line without having to pull on the skin during its application. This unique eyeliner is perfect for older women or women who want a top-shelf liner made specifically for sensitive skin.

Read more about this liner on Amazon.

What color eyeliner should an older woman wear?

Most makeup experts recommend that women of a certain age avoid black eyeliner. The reason is that black is pretty harsh against the skin and can exaggerate fine lines and wrinkles. It can also make mature eyes appear smaller. Softer colors such as brown, lavender, in moss green can do wonders to enhance the eyes and make the eyes appear larger.

How do you apply eyeliner over 60?

Close up of a eyeliner pencil drawing in assorted colors

The texture and shape of your skin are bound to change as you get older. This usually means that slight shifts in your eye makeup routine are needed to achieve optimal results. Here are a few tips to help you improve your eyeliner application routine.

Consider liquid liners

Most liquid liners have a felt-tip, allowing you to easily control the liner without tugging and pulling on your skin. Liquid liners also do a great job of filling in lines and wrinkles.

Always use a primer

Moisturizers and eye creams can work as great primers. Primers help to protect your skin from makeup residue and will keep it moisturized throughout the day.

Don't use an underliner

Oftentimes, underliners can make mature eyes look smaller than they are. Instead of using this method, consider applying a bit of mascara to the lower lash to add a bit of definition to the eye's bottom.

Take a look at this Maybelline mascara on Amazon.

Consider a white liner

White liner isn't mentioned as often as dark eyeliners, but it's one of the best ways to offer an instant eye lift. If you are looking for a secret weapon to make your eyes look wider and more defined, consider applying a smudge-proof white liner.

Learn more about this L'Oreal white liner on Amazon.

How can I brighten my older eyes?

The most common recommendations for brightening older eyes include using under-eye brighteners and concealers around the eye. Other noteworthy mentions include applying eyeliner to your waterline and highlighting the inner corners of your eyes.

Find this L’Oréal concealer on Amazon

Should an older woman wear mascara on lower lashes?

You'll often hear a resounding "No" as an answer to this question. The reason is that it can make mature eyes look droopy and draw attention to any dark circles that may be beneath the eye. It's best to stick to the outer corners and the top lashes. Also, another option is to go with a dark liner on the bottom lid.

Check out this mascara by Urban Decay on Amazon.

Wrapping Things Up

Older women looking to enhance their looks with eyeliner can benefit from buying eyeliners that are easy to use, waterproof, and have long-lasting times. With age, applying eyeliner and other types of makeup can damage your skin, so it's important to consider what features will work best for you.

Before you go, be sure to check out our other posts:

How To Use Lip Liner With Lip Gloss

How To Apply Lipstick Without Lip Liner

One comment

  1. I have bought this NYX Professional Makeup Eye Liner for my mother. The pencil was easy to use and she even used it on her waterline because she have small eyes and that stayed on all day as well. This eye liner is a good quality and does not irritate the eyes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *