What Color Eyebrow Pencil For Gray Hair?

We may get commissions for purchases made through links in this post. 

If you’ve decided to embrace your natural gray hair, you may be wondering how to handle your eyebrows. We’ve done the research and have the best eyebrow styling advice, whether your eyebrows have gone gray along with your hair or not.

The best color eyebrow pencil for gray hair depends on the underlying tones in your hair and the color of your eyebrows. Try the following:

  • Use a dark brown eyebrow pencil if you still have dark tones in your gray hair. 
  • Use a gray eyebrow pencil two shades darker than your hair if your eyebrows are already completely gray and your gray hair is light. 
  • Use a taupe eyebrow pencil if you still have blonde in your gray hair. 
  • Whatever color you choose, make sure the shade coordinates with your skin undertone.  

You may need to adjust your makeup palette to make the most of your gray hair. Read on to find out more about choosing the best eyebrow pencil for your gray hair based on your skin tone, as well as how to coordinate your eyebrows to compliment your colored hair.

A senior woman getting her eyebrows angled by a beautician in a beauty salon, What Color Eyebrow Pencil For Gray Hair?

Use a Dark Brown Eyebrow Pencil if Your Gray Hair Has Dark Tones

A beautiful senior woman with gray hair smiling

For hair that is more salt-and-pepper gray than all-over gray, you can use a brown eyebrow pencil that matches the darker color in your hair. With this approach, the gray in your hair is treated more like highlights. Your brows will stay darker to frame your face.

Click here to shop for brown eyebrow pencils on Amazon.

You can use the eyebrow pencil to color in any grays in your eyebrows if you want to go for a dramatic look, or you can fill in around your grays to keep the highlighted look going. For an everyday style, add a few strokes of the pencil anywhere your eyebrows are thin. You can achieve a more dramatic look by going a shade darker than normal and filling in your brows heavier than you normally would.

Close up of blue eyed woman with beautiful brown shade smokey eye makeup

Use a Gray Eyebrow Pencil Two Shades Darker Than Your Hair

If your hair is completely gray, you can go with a gray eyebrow pencil that’s about two shades darker than your hair. If your eyebrows are the same shade as your hair, they can make your face look washed out. Another option is two use two shades of gray eyebrow pencil. Use the darker pencil as a base and the lighter one for highlights as an accent.

Click here to shop for gray eyebrow pencils on Amazon.

Use a Taupe Eyebrow Pencil If Your Underlying Hair Color is Blonde

Gray hair tends to blend very well with light blonde hair, often making it difficult to tell where the blonde ends and the gray begins. If you still have a significant amount of blonde in your hair, choose an eyebrow pencil in taupe or blonde that is two shades darker than your hair. This will give you an elegant but natural look.

Beautiful mature woman standing against gray background

If your hair is darker blonde, you can go with a light brown eyebrow pencil. You may even need to go with a medium brown to get some definition. It’s important to consider the overall shade of your hair rather than just the darkest or lightest colors.

Click here to check out blonde eyebrow pencils on Amazon.

Choose an Eyebrow Pencil That Looks Good With Your Skin’s Undertone

If your makeup seems a little off since you’ve gone gray, you may need to reevaluate your skin’s undertone. As you age, you tend to lose contrast in your facial features. This can make you look washed out. Using slightly stronger colors can help compensate for this loss of contrast.

A beautiful elderly woman enjoys the great outdoors

If you’re using more intense colors, you need to make sure they’re the right colors for your skin tone. To start, it’s important to know if you have a warm, cool, or neutral undertone. The easiest way to determine your skin’s undertone is to look at your inner wrist in natural sunlight.

If your veins are green, you have warm undertones. If your veins are blue or purplish, you have cool undertones. If your veins are a mix of blue and green or a shade in between, you have neutral undertones. Choose a brow pencil in a shade that matches your undertone.

Click here to see this eyebrow palette kit on Amazon.

Eyebrow pencils come in a dizzying array of colors. Smear the eyebrow pencil on the back of your hand if you’re having trouble determining its undertone. This will help you see the undertones as well as see the color directly against your skin.

Eyebrow pencils with cool undertones will have pinkish shades. If you need a pencil with warm undertones, look for shades with more yellow. Neutral tones fall somewhere in between.

Brown eyebrow pencils on white background

Is There a Gray Eyebrow Pencil?

There are gray eyebrow pencils to match any shade of hair. The days of eyebrow pencils coming only in shades of brown are over. You can find eyebrow pencils in any natural or natural shade you like. While gray may seem like a neutral shade, it can have warm, cool, or neutral tones like other colors.

How Do You Know Which Eyebrow Pencil to Use?

You need to consider your hair color, your overall coloring, and your skin tone when you’re trying to decide which eyebrow pencil to use. Make sure you examine your hair and skin in natural sunlight when you’re checking for undertones. Fluorescent lights or other sources of artificial light can alter colors and give you a false sense of your undertones.

Should Eyebrows Be Darker or Lighter Than Your Hair?

In general, your eyebrows should be around two shades darker than your hair. It’s important to match the undertone of hair, though. If your gray hair has cool undertones, your brows should be darker but with the same cool undertones.

A beautiful senior woman with gray hair

Eyebrows are naturally a little darker than your hair on everyone except those with the darkest shades of hair. If your hair is very dark and just sprinkled with gray highlights, you can match the darker color in your hair.

One of the best things about gray hair is the variety of choices you have regarding makeup. If your hair isn’t completely gray, you can choose a darker shade of your original color. For hair that’s over half gray, you can either choose a darker shade of your original color or a darker shade of your gray.

Click here to shop for eyebrow stencil kits on Amazon.

Studies have shown that people with more contrast in their faces are seen as more attractive. If your eyebrows match your hair exactly, it creates less contrast in your face. This is especially true with white gray or blonde hair. Very light eyebrows can almost disappear.

How Do I Match My Eyebrows to Dyed Hair?

Unless your hair is dyed an unnatural color such as pink or purple (which can look fantastic on gray hair), you should follow the same rules for matching dyed hair as you would for matching natural hair. Your eyebrows should be slightly darker than your hair for all but the darkest hair colors.

Woman dyeing gray hair root with brush and hair color

In Closing

With some careful consideration about the best shades and undertones for your complexion, your eyebrows can look fabulous and natural with your gray hair. Whether you’re letting your natural gray grow out or embracing the gray look with hair dye, choosing the right eyebrow pencil color will make sure you look fabulous.

If you’re looking for more style inspiration, check out these posts:

Does Lipstick Fade Your Lip Color?

Are Microblading Eyebrows Permanent?

Leave a Reply